deniz.in

Markets

Weather

Loading weather

· via The Verge

Apple HomeView audio retested: CarPlay app limits, no stereo pairing and Siri routing quirks

Follow-up testing by The Verge finds Apple's HomeView cannot be stereo-paired, wall-mounted audio is thin, and Spotify, Audible and other third-party apps inherit CarPlay's driving-focused limits.

Apple HomeView audio retested: CarPlay app limits, no stereo pairing and Siri routing quirks

Follow-up testing answers HomeView audio questions

The Verge has published a follow-up to its review of the HomeView, Apple's first smart display, after readers raised questions about how the device holds up as a smart speaker. The additional testing, published November 22, covers sound quality, stereo pairing, AirPlay behaviour and third-party music app support, and it surfaces several limitations buyers should weigh before treating the HomeView as a serious speaker.

Sound: closer to a HomePod Mini than a full-size speaker

According to The Verge, the HomeView is not a substitute for a Sonos One or a full-size HomePod, both of which sound noticeably better. In size and sound, the tabletop HomeView sits closer to the HomePod Mini: it produces stronger bass and plays slightly louder than a Mini 2, but it is less clear and does not fill a room as effectively.

The hardware explains the gap. The Mini 2 uses a single full-range driver plus two passive radiators, while the tabletop HomeView places two drivers in the display and a woofer plus two passive radiators in its base. Because the display sits partly over that base, it interferes with the sound. Apple fitted the display with an accelerometer so the device can retune its EQ in real time as the screen is tilted. The HomeView does support Spatial Audio with Dolby Atmos, which the Mini 2 lacks.

The wall-mounted variant is weaker still. It carries only two drivers, with computational audio that Apple says is "tuned specifically for on-wall placement," and The Verge describes its output as noticeably thinner, with essentially no bass. The reviewer would not buy it for sound quality, though it works fine for talking to a visitor through a video doorbell.

No stereo pairing

Two HomeViews cannot be linked as a stereo pair, and a HomeView cannot be paired with a HomePod or HomePod Mini either. You can group a HomeView with other AirPlay speakers so that everything plays at once, but a true stereo setup is off the table. The Verge's reviewer suggests that anyone with roughly $300 to spend purely on sound would be better served by two HomePod Minis; the HomeView's real advantage is its screen, which works like a jukebox for browsing songs, podcasts and audiobooks rather than relying on Siri or a phone.

AirPlay and handoff mostly behave

AirPlay functions as it does on any other AirPlay speaker, and tap-to-handoff works the way it does on HomePods, in either direction. New to the HomeView, handoff also covers video. The Verge successfully transferred Apple TV, Apple Music, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pocket Casts, YouTube Music, FaceTime and phone calls, although calls occasionally dropped. YouTube and YouTube TV video handed off despite lacking an app on the device, while Netflix and Amazon Prime Video moved audio only. One irritation: handoff is aggressive, and a phone held within a few inches of the display will keep trying to grab the audio.

Speaker routing favours Apple's own apps

There is no setting to make another speaker the default output in place of the built-in one, though you can direct audio to any AirPlay speaker or group. The Verge tested this with HomePods, Sonos speakers and a Samsung TV and found it smooth. Native apps such as Apple Music, Podcasts and Safari remember the last speakers used and reconnect automatically. Third-party apps like Spotify and Audible, along with Apple apps built on the CarPlay interface such as Apple News and Apple TV, honour the last-used speakers only when you pick content on the HomeView's own screen. Ask Siri instead and audio goes to the HomeView itself unless you spell out a destination, a step Apple Music does not require.

Third-party apps are CarPlay ports

Most of these quirks share one root cause: Apple did not build a dedicated app platform for the HomeView. It reuses CarPlay, so any audio or video app that supports CarPlay works on the display and nothing else does. In practice, The Verge found, that means third-party apps require your user profile and your phone on the same Wi-Fi network, so only you can use them. They load and respond more slowly than the built-in apps, and none offers a search field or keyboard, because CarPlay assumes you are driving rather than standing in a kitchen. The reviewer tested Pocket Casts, Amazon Music, YouTube Music, Spotify and Audible; all appeared in the app drawer and could play audio, but playback was buggy, with the music control screen sometimes failing to appear and Audible frequently refusing to load at all. Even Apple's own TV app, currently the only CarPlay video app supported, opens with a warning to make sure you are stationary before watching.

Why it matters

The HomeView's audio shortcomings flow from a single platform decision: porting a car interface to a stationary household device. Until Apple ships a proper HomeView app framework or relaxes CarPlay's driving-oriented constraints, third-party music services will remain second-class citizens on the hardware, and buyers who care about sound should budget for separate speakers. The case for the HomeView is the screen, not the speaker.

  • #apple
  • #smart-home
  • #smart-speakers
  • #carplay
  • #audio