deniz.in

Markets

Weather

Loading weather

· via The Verge

New York, LA and Chicago schools weigh leaving Google Search over mandatory Gemini features

Google says schools that turn off its Gemini-powered features will also lose Search, pushing the largest US school districts to evaluate alternatives.

New York, LA and Chicago schools weigh leaving Google Search over mandatory Gemini features

Google ties classroom Search to Gemini

Starting next year, schools will no longer be able to disable Google's Gemini-powered features without also disabling Search, according to The New York Times, whose reporting was covered by The Verge. Chris Phillips, Google's vice president of education, told the Times that "Search and AI are deeply integrated," and that schools that turn off the AI features "will not have access to Search."

The change puts the largest school districts in the United States, New York, Los Angeles and Chicago, in the position of rethinking a product that has been the default doorway to the web for a generation of students. All three are now considering alternatives to Google Search, the Times reports.

Officials call it extortion

The policy has drawn an unusually blunt reaction from elected officials. According to The Verge, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Senator Bernie Sanders have both described Google's behavior as "extortion." The clash is especially charged in New York, where Mamdani had recently announced a policy barring the city's youngest students from using AI in the classroom.

New York City schools chancellor Kamar H. Samuels told the Times, "If Google doesn't reconsider their position, we will explore other search options." Chicago's public schools have delivered a similar message, reportedly telling Google that if it cannot provide a version of Search without AI, "the district will look to other search solutions."

Google's answer: step-by-step Search and off-by-default controls

In a statement to The Verge, Google spokesperson Laura Breen said the company hears parents' and teachers' concerns about students using AI to shortcut learning, shares the goal of helping students learn, and is building the new experiences in partnership with educators.

Two specifics stand out in her statement. Google is beginning to pilot "Guided Learning" capabilities in Search this month, designed to walk students through complex problems step by step instead of handing over quick answers. And next year, Google says it will update its approach to controls for schools so that the Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search are all off by default until schools decide which services to enable.

That second change addresses how services get switched on, but not the districts' central complaint: once Search is enabled, running it without Gemini appears to no longer be an option.

Leaving Google is easier said than done

Educators' unease about AI in the classroom goes beyond this dispute. As The Verge notes, educators are wary of AI's effect on students' critical thinking skills, some studies have shown that students who use AI generally perform worse on tests, and there are concerns about the mental health effects on children who develop relationships with chatbots at a young age.

At the same time, Google is deeply embedded in American classrooms through Google Classroom, Chromebooks and other services, and The Verge points out that going fully Google-free would likely prove difficult. Swapping one search box for another is the simple part of a migration; the surrounding ecosystem is what locks districts in.

Why it matters

This is one of the clearest public tests yet of whether bundling AI into an essential, near-universal tool will be tolerated by institutional customers. Schools are unusual among Google's users: they buy at enormous scale, answer to elected officials, and have specific pedagogical reasons to want AI kept out of the loop. If districts as large as New York, Los Angeles and Chicago can credibly threaten to walk away, it could pressure Google to unbundle the two products; if they cannot, it signals that AI integration in default products is effectively non-negotiable, a question that extends well beyond classrooms to any organization that depends on a single dominant provider.

  • #google
  • #gemini
  • #search
  • #education
  • #edtech

Related posts