· via Hacker News – Front Page (hnrss.org)
Quad9 pulls its 9.9.9.9 DNS resolver out of France over piracy-blocking court fine
Swiss non-profit Quad9 will stop resolving DNS for France on November 24 after a Paris court fined it €1,000 a day for refusing to block sports piracy sites, with about 20 similar cases still pending.

Quad9 is leaving France
Quad9, the Swiss non-profit behind the free 9.9.9.9 DNS resolver, will stop answering queries from France on November 24. Founded in 2017 by the Global Cyber Alliance, IBM and Packet Clearing House, the organisation is not leaving over costs or lack of users: it is leaving because a Paris court fined it for refusing to block pirate sports-streaming domains, and with roughly 20 similar cases still pending in France, Quad9 says staying is not financially survivable. The account of the dispute was published by TechStackUps and surfaced on the front page of Hacker News.
Cloudflare, which runs the competing 1.1.1.1 resolver, called the departure "a canary in the coal mine", and Quad9's CTO John Todd used the Hacker News thread to ask readers to send well-sourced arguments against France's approach to policymakers.
The fine and the reasoning behind it
The legal basis is Article L.333-10 of the French Code du sport, a 2021 provision that lets sports rightsholders obtain "dynamic" blocking orders against any party able to help remedy infringement — wording French courts have read as covering DNS resolvers. According to the report, a July 2026 law added an automated real-time blocking system run by the regulator Arcom; TorrentFreak reported that Arcom agents no longer approve each block in advance, a change Quad9 has called "recklessly dangerous".
In May 2026, beIN Sports obtained an order requiring Quad9 to block IPTV sites carrying the WTA women's tennis tour. The list started at six domains and grew to 58 through Arcom notifications. beIN asked for €10,000 per day for each domain still reachable — up to €580,000 a day — but on October 21 the judge set the penalty at €1,000 per day in total, running until the season ended on November 14.
Two parts of the ruling matter beyond the sums. The court observed that Quad9 already applies automated, global filtering for cybersecurity and "appears to contradict itself" in claiming it cannot block — treating the ability to drop malware domains everywhere as proof it can drop piracy domains for France. And because Quad9 was bound by an obligation of means, its statement that it was implementing no measures at all was, in the court's view, sufficient on its own to justify a penalty.
A widening circle of targets
Quad9 is the latest target, not the first. Canal+ sued Cloudflare, Google and Cisco under the same article in December 2023; in mid-2024 the Paris court ordered the three resolvers to block roughly 117 domains, Google complied, and Cisco withdrew OpenDNS from France in June 2024. In December 2024 Canal+ won orders against Quad9 and Vercara, and Quad9 — unable to geolocate users — blocked the listed domains worldwide, saying it had to block them "for all users, in all areas". In March 2026 the Paris Court of Appeal rejected appeals by Google, Cloudflare and Cisco, holding that any filtering measure can be circumvented and that this "does not render the measures in question ineffective". By April 2026 the EU-funded DNS4EU resolver was complying globally, and July brought 14 new Canal+ orders against ISPs, resolvers, VPN providers and Bing. On October 7 the court declined to penalise Cloudflare, NordVPN and Surfshark because each had made some blocking effort, with Cloudflare keeping 1.1.1.1 out of scope by acting through its CDN.
Why Quad9 says it cannot comply
Global blocking means a French court decides what a user in Brazil, Kenya or Germany may resolve, for the commercial benefit of one company — and once that is accepted, every court in every country can add names to everyone's resolver. Geo-blocking only France is no clean escape: Quad9 has already attempted geographically limited blocking in Germany, in the Sony Music litigation. Staying and paying is arithmetically impossible — a few weeks of the current fine comes to roughly €24,000, but twenty parallel cases running full seasons with ever-growing domain lists do not. Quad9's own statement is blunt: it "cannot survive the accumulation of penalties" in the pending cases.
Who breaks when a resolver disappears
Devices pointed at 9.9.9.9 will show no error. As Cloudflare puts it, "Their Internet will simply stop working." The blast radius inside France is large: according to Quad9's announcement, French traffic includes government digital directorate DINUM, France Travail, the CEA, the Institut Pasteur, research network RENATER, EDF, SNCF, Marseille's AP-HM hospitals, France Télévisions, Thales and Airbus subsidiary Stormshield. Mullvad shut down its own public DNS service on November 2 and moved default Mullvad Browser users onto Quad9 with funding — three weeks before the cutoff. Because Quad9 keeps no user records, a design choice tied to its 2021 move to Zürich so its privacy promises would be backed by Swiss law, it cannot warn any of them.
Why it matters
The precedent cuts several ways. A court has treated a resolver's security filtering as evidence that commercial filtering is equally feasible; an obligation of means means that refusing to attempt compliance is itself punishable; and open infrastructure is proving exit-driven — Cisco left in 2024, Quad9 leaves in 2026, and each departure silently breaks connectivity for users, including public institutions, who never chose a side in a sports rights dispute. Quad9 claims more than 670 million malicious-domain blocks a day across over 230 resolver clusters in 110+ countries; a country that drives it out loses that protection too.
- #dns
- #quad9
- #france
- #piracy
- #internet-governance