· via Hacker News – Front Page (hnrss.org)
ICE pays AT&T millions for access to trillions of call records, 404 Media reports
Internal ICE documents obtained by 404 Media show AT&T is paid millions to let agency analysts query raw call records, a program experts liken to the defunct Hemisphere surveillance system.

ICE is paying AT&T millions of dollars for access to the carrier's raw call data and a team of AT&T analysts who search through it, according to 404 Media, which obtained a restricted ICE procurement document through a Freedom of Information Act request. Civil liberties experts who reviewed the records describe the arrangement as mass surveillance, with an underlying database they say holds trillions of phone records, including location information.
A successor to Hemisphere
The AT&T offering appears in the records under two names, Data Analytics and Support Services and Data Analytical Services, and seems to be descended from Hemisphere, an earlier AT&T program that gave federal, state and local authorities access to subscriber data. Hemisphere was shut down after Senator Ron Wyden and Representative Biggs repeatedly challenged it, but according to the document 404 Media obtained, ICE is still buying raw data access under the newer arrangement. Wyden told 404 Media the current administration has effectively revived the defunct program and handed it to ICE.
How the arrangement works
The procurement document describes a sole-source purchase: AT&T analysts convert the company's raw data into a usable format and provide technical interpretation for Homeland Security Investigations, the criminal investigative arm of ICE. HSI has historically concentrated on cases such as cybercrime and child abuse, but 404 Media reports it has been redirected toward immigration violations and voter-fraud investigations under the Trump administration. The document says the data supports a broad range of HSI investigations; the specific categories are redacted.
A separate document obtained by Wyden's office, supplied by the Office of National Drug Control Policy, the White House-affiliated entity that previously funded Hemisphere, lists the program's capabilities. They include tying multiple devices or phone numbers to a single identified person, flagging when a target has swapped a SIM card, determining whether a phone linked to an international target has entered the United States, and untangling international numbers associated with targets. Documents previously obtained by the EFF and EPIC indicate the database contains more than a trillion phone records.
Non-customers get swept in too
Surveillance expert Christopher Soghoian, who worked for Wyden for a decade, told 404 Media that AT&T also carries wholesale traffic for other phone companies. That means it can collect, retain and mine records of calls made by other carriers' customers, including conversations in which neither party uses AT&T. The practical consequence, as Soghoian put it, is that consumers cannot protect their privacy by switching carriers.
Money and legal questions
Public procurement records show ICE paid AT&T more than $2.1 million in 2025 and more than $2.2 million this August, with total spending potentially exceeding ten million dollars over the coming years. The restricted document notes that demand for the data rose during fiscal 2025 and that a further significant increase in use is anticipated. It also states that AT&T is the only vendor with the ability to reach this data, and that if AT&T stops performing the analysis, the capability is lost.
AT&T told 404 Media that it has long served as a connectivity partner to government agencies and that it is required by law to hand over information to government and law enforcement. Experts counter that the threshold is an administrative subpoena, which agencies can issue themselves without a judge's approval, leaving ICE wide latitude in how it uses the data. Jeramie Scott of EPIC described the deal as indiscriminate surveillance effectively sold to law enforcement as a paid service, deployed without judicial oversight or a privacy impact assessment, and said the presence of location data raises questions under the Supreme Court's Carpenter and Chatrie rulings, which held that police generally need a warrant for phone location information.
The Financial Times previously reported on the public procurement records, but not on the restricted document 404 Media later obtained.
Why it matters
This story exposes how a major carrier can monetize data retained for ordinary network operations, turning call and location records into a subscription product for government investigators. The scale is remarkable — reportedly more than a trillion records — and the reach extends beyond AT&T's own customers, meaning there is no consumer escape hatch. The legal footing rests on administrative subpoenas rather than judicial warrants, which privacy groups argue sidesteps the constitutional safeguards the Supreme Court has attached to location data. If the arrangement survives scrutiny, it offers a template other agencies could copy, and it shows how programs officially shut down can quietly persist under new names.
- #surveillance
- #privacy
- #telecom
- #law-enforcement
- #foia