deniz.in

Markets

Weather

Loading weather

· via TechCrunch

UK tribunal forces government to confirm secret order demanding Apple break encryption

The UK's Investigatory Powers Tribunal has ordered the government to confirm it issued a secret notice demanding access to Apple's encrypted customer data, rejecting national security arguments against disclosure.

UK tribunal forces government to confirm secret order demanding Apple break encryption

The UK government has been ordered to confirm that it issued a secret demand for access to Apple customers' encrypted data, after the country's Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected the argument that acknowledging the order would harm national security.

According to TechCrunch, the ruling was issued on Thursday by the Investigatory Powers Tribunal, an independent court that hears challenges to government surveillance. Rights group Liberty International, which brought the case on behalf of two individuals, said it marks the first known time the UK government has been compelled to admit that a secret technical order of this kind exists.

A year-long standoff over encrypted iCloud data

The dispute began roughly a year earlier, when the UK government reportedly demanded that Apple create a backdoor allowing authorities to reach encrypted customer data anywhere in the world. The demand took the form of a technical capabilities notice, a category of order issued under strict non-disclosure rules that legally barred Apple from revealing it, even after its contents leaked to the media.

Those leaks drew criticism from White House officials and US lawmakers, who argued the order would put Americans' privacy at risk, TechCrunch reports.

Apple refused to build the requested access. Instead, the company blocked UK users from turning on Advanced Data Protection, its end-to-end encryption feature for iCloud, rather than comply with the demand. The government later narrowed the order to cover data belonging to British nationals stored in Apple's encrypted cloud, and Apple challenged that revised version as well.

The ruling and what remains sealed

The Home Office had contended that confirming the order's existence would damage national security. The tribunal rejected that claim, a rare rebuke for a government that had fought to keep the encryption demand a state secret.

As of publication, the Home Office had not confirmed that a notice exists and did not respond to a request for comment, according to TechCrunch. Apple also did not respond following the ruling, though the company has previously said it has never built hidden access of this kind into its products and services and never will.

A further hearing expected next year will decide exactly which details of the order can be made public, meaning the full text of the demand and its precise technical requirements may stay sealed for now.

Why it matters

This is the first known instance of the UK government being forced to acknowledge a secret technical order, and it weakens the non-disclosure regime that has historically kept such demands invisible. Because technical capability notices can compel companies to engineer access to encrypted services, the precedent reaches well beyond Apple: any provider operating in the UK could face similar demands, and the case demonstrates that those orders can be challenged and partially exposed.

The stakes are also international. The original demand reportedly sought access to customer data worldwide, prompting objections from US officials who said it would endanger Americans' privacy, while UK users have already lost access to iCloud's strongest encryption setting as a consequence of the standoff. How much of the order is ultimately published after next year's hearing will shape future legal fights over government demands for access to encrypted data.

  • #encryption
  • #privacy
  • #apple
  • #uk
  • #surveillance

Related posts